TBT – Airtest of the two-seat Jodel

27
This post was originally published on this site

This week’ s Throwback Thursday feature {from the|from your|through the} Australian Aviation archive {is this|is|are these claims} November 2008 airtest {of the|from the|in the} two-seat Jodel by Bob Grimstead.

Flight test {of the|from the|in the} Jodel. (Bob Grimstead)

Jodels are neat, light, dainty and highly efficient, French designed, wood-and-fabric tailwheel aeroplanes.

Mostly they use trusty four-cylinder Continental A65, A75, C-85, C-90 or O-200 engines, although some later, lighter versions have Volkswagens or Jabirus. Jodels have a comparatively high cruise speed {on their|on the|issues} low (and therefore economical) power, thanks to their {light weight|lightweight|light-weight}, low drag and that efficient, semi-tapered and noticeably cranked wing that is their trademark. All Jodels have good short-field performance, and their handling is fairly benign for tailwheelers, although the four-seaters in particular {can be|could be|may be} amusing to fly {with a|having a|using a} rearward centre of gravity – especially on or off {a hard|a tough|a difficult} runway.

{The word|The term|The phrase} Jodel came from combining {the two|both|the 2} designers’ names: CFI and aircraft maintenance engineer Edouard Joly and aeronautical engineer Jean Dé lé montez, both of whom were accomplished homebuilders. These guys (subsequently father- and son-in-law) built their first, single-seat, open cockpit Jodel (the D. 9 Bé bé ) in 1946, just for fun. Having sketched its lines directly onto the structure, {they were|these were|we were holding} poorly placed when {asked for|requested|called for} production drawings. The Jodel family later became big, spanning many models, {with the|using the|with all the} wooden Robins as later derivatives.

All Jodels have cranked wings and predominantly wooden construction. They might be either homebuilt or factory-produced (by several firms), and it can often be {difficult to|hard to|challenging to} differentiate between the different models visually. Here I shall {concentrate on|focus on|pay attention to} two factory-built two-seaters built by SAN and Wassmer respectively, although at least half the Jodels flying {around the world are|all over the world are|around the globe are} actually amateur built.

Older Jodels were often partly or wholly assembled with water-based casein glue (although other glues have also been used, particularly in later years), so they {should never be|is never} left outside. Many are {50 years|5 decades} old, and it only takes one wet winter {in the open|on view} to cause trouble. Beware a shiny new coat of paint, which might cover underlying problems. If you are {thinking of|considering|thinking about} buying one, it is well worth {giving it a|offering it a} thorough inspection, since {finding a|getting a|locating a} LAME sufficiently skilled in wood and fabric construction can be difficult these days, and any structural repair will inevitably be time consuming and therefore expensive.

At 348kg, G-BBPS can lift full fuel (82kg), two 80kg blokes and even 20kg of baggage as well, while still being within its 617kg maximum takeoff weight. (Bob Grimstead)

At 348kg, G-BBPS can lift full fuel (82kg), two 80kg blokes {and even|as well as|and also} 20kg of baggage as well, while still being within its 617kg maximum takeoff weight. (Bob Grimstead)

Serious structural deterioration is not unknown, and it is {not unheard of|known}, upon stripping the dacron from a Jodel’ s control surfaces, to discover that the structure is only held together {by the|from the|with the} fabric! Control horns occasionally come loose, so it is {a good idea to|a smart idea to|smart to} grip the surfaces and waggle these horns {to check|to check on|to evaluate}.

Also check underneath the entire airframe; ensure there are plenty of drain holes, {and they are|plus they are|and perhaps they are} not blocked. Remove all inspection panels; wing and fuselage interiors can easily be inspected through these, and have {a good|a great|an excellent} sniff at each hole. Any hint of the odour of mushrooms reveals rot, which must be investigated before further flight. Tap the ribs’ upper surfaces – {a change|a big change|an alteration} in note from one {to another|to a different|to a new} could indicate glue failure.

Minor flying control or wing rib repairs are fairly simple (and therefore inexpensive) to fix, but spar damage can be costly. Water inevitably drains {to the|towards the|for the} trailing edges, so waggle these to reveal glue failure. Tug the ailerons {to assess|to evaluate} their supporting false spar’ s integrity. Check for wing walkway sponginess; there could be rot here if the aeroplane {has been|continues to be|have been} outside for long.

Inspect the main undercarriage mountings. Jodel main legs break away from their attach plates if overloaded, particularly sideways, so ensure both legs are straight. Check the mainwheel tracking; they should be parallel to the aeroplane’ s centreline, but are {supposed to be|said to be|allowed to be} slightly angled outwards {at the top|at the very top|towards the top}. D. 120s use special brake fluid and have scissor links, which wear. The D. 117s’ unusually narrow 420 by 150 tyres are no longer available, but modern American alternatives are. Owner Andy’ s red Jodel {has a|includes a|contains a} disc brake modification, {rather than|instead of|as opposed to} its original, not very effective French drum brakes.

Significant fuselage problems can require costly re-skinning. Wing spar to fuselage, tailplane and tail spring bolts often suffer from serious corrosion because the French manufacturers {did not|failed to|would not} routinely use chromate anti-corrosion paste. These should be removed regularly for checking. {If they are|If they happen to be|Credit rating} seized, do not ignore it; that could indicate advanced corrosion going on inside.

Wooden airframes (and propellers) expand and shrink with humidity variations, so it is {important to|crucial to|essential to} check the propeller attachment bolts and control cables every couple of months to ensure adequate tension. Waggle the controls and listen for excessive friction in the cables, which {run over|stepped on} pulleys and through fibre friction blocks. Loose cables wear prematurely, so {should be|must be|ought to be} fixed soon, and replaced if exhibiting significant wear.

All cowlings can be subject to vibration damage. Fixing this early {with a|having a|using a} small fibreglass repair {is easy|is simple|is not hard}, but leaving it and having a cowling depart {in flight|flying} could be catastrophic. (The same is true of canopies. )

These small Continental engines are normally very reliable (although rather prone to carburettor icing). They do prefer to be warmed gently, and to have regular oil changes (every three months or 25 hours, whichever is sooner), so check the logbooks. Exhaust cracks are always problematic, and can be impossible to find without removal of {the whole|the entire|the complete} system.

{Do check|Check} the empty weight, although with these small Jodels {it is|it really is|it truly is} rarely a problem. At 348kg, G-BBPS (the red one) can lift full fuel (82kg), two 80kg blokes and even 20kg of baggage {as well|too|at the same time}, while still being within its 617kg max takeoff weight.

{Inside the|Within the|In the} aeroplane, do check the shoulder harness attachments. Originally {only a|just a|merely a} lap strap was fitted, and some shoulder straps have unsatisfactory anchorages.

G-BBPS’s standard panel contains six primary instruments. (Bob Grimstead)

G-BBPS’ s standard panel contains six primary instruments. (Bob Grimstead)

The canopy’s draught sealing looks rudimentary (and it can be difficult to source replacements) but it actually works well in flight. (Bob Grimstead)

The canopy’ s draught sealing looks rudimentary (and it can be difficult to source replacements) but it actually works well in flight. (Bob Grimstead)

My collection of post-1979 Jodel Club newsletters covers recurring maintenance topics like: brake adjustment, repair and replacement; undercarriage rubbers and servicing; fuel pump and cock repair and replacement; tailwheel springs and shimmying; and sourcing parts. This has mostly been solved by British enthusiast Pete Smoothy’ s Airworld (UK).

All Jodels are tailwheelers, with proper control columns, sprightly handling, great all-round visibility and excellent cruise performance, so they probably {appeal to|attract|interest} the more outgoing and adventurous among us. Most of the single and two-seaters have no flaps, {but some|however, many|sometimes} do have spoilers to increase their descent angle for landing.

Jodels are prized by folk who appreciate value for money, particularly if they enjoy rolling up their sleeves and working on {their own|their very own|their particular} aeroplanes – and their structures, systems and Continental engines are not complex, so this is far from difficult.

Lucié n Qué rey was an enthusiastic aeromodeller and glider pilot, a dynamic businessman, and an early Jodel convert. His SAN factory initially concentrated on equipping previously constructed Jodel D. 112s with radios {but ,|however} realising the type’ s potential, he obtained a licence to build production models. Re-designated and improved {as the|since the|because the} D. 117, the first {of these was|of those was|of such was} completed in 1953. Qué rey later felt his Jodels didn’ t {have enough|have sufficient} drag for a sensible approach angle, so he designed and fitted under-wing spoilers or airbrakes as an option. His company, SAN, eventually sold 1098 Jodels. The red-flashed example in these photos is a 1957 SAN Jodel D. 117 with a 90hp (67kW) Continental C-90-14F engine.

Wassmer {was a|was obviously a} woodworking concern in another {part of|a part of|portion of} France that started building Jodels in 1955. Altogether, they made 712 D. 112s (with 65hp/48kW engines) and D. 120s (with 90hp/67kW engines). The blue-flashed Jodel illustrated here is a 1960 Wassmer Jodel D. 120A (the A is for airbrakes) with the same 90hp (67kW) Continental engine as the other aeroplane.

G-BJYK is a 1960 Wassmer built Jodel D.120A (the A is for airbrakes). (Bob Grimstead)

G-BJYK is a 1960 Wassmer built Jodel D. 120A (the A {is for|is perfect for|is made for} airbrakes). (Bob Grimstead)

Any little Jodel is a friendly aeroplane, with a structure that is very light for its size but remarkably strong. Hand-built from spruce, gaboon ply and Ceconite fabric, at just 350kg, most Jodels are far lighter than a 535kg Cessna 152 or Piper Tomahawk, {and yet|but|yet}, with +5. 6/-2. 8g design load factors, {much stronger|stronger} than both those boring metal aeroplanes.

The classic Jodel cranked wing uses the common NACA 23012 aerofoil. Out on its upturned tips are simple, unsophisticated, constant-chord ailerons with very little differential action. The red example here has no flaps, {but the|however the|nevertheless the} otherwise similar blue {one has|you have|speculate if this trade} the under-belly airbrakes {that work|basically} like flaps for landing.

Despite its rounded top-decking, the Jodel fuselage is basically a slab-sided, rectangular cross-section plywood box, so it needs no fin other than the small fibreglass fillet that distinguishes a SAN D. 117 from a Wassmer D. 120. The all-flying rudder is generously-sized, {and there is|and} a conventional fixed tailplane, plus dual elevators with a small trim tab. As well as the standard, all-flying fin/rudder, some later Jodels also used an all-flying ‘ monobloc’ tailplane or stabilator.

The fuselage sits {at a|in a|with a} low ground angle, giving good forward visibility. Fuel is contained in two tanks. The front one ahead of the cockpit holds 60 litres, and must be used for takeoff and landing, while the rear tank under the baggage shelf holds an additional 55 litres. A stout transverse handle {in the|within the|inside the} rear fuselage, which the D. 120A lacks, aids ground manhandling the D. 117.

With doors on both sides of the cabin, you enter by hopping up on to the low trailing-edge of either wing, moving carefully forward along the walkway to avoid puncturing the wing’ s fabric covering, and lifting a canopy half. These latch open, and although hinged along the middle, {they do not|they cannot|they don’t} touch like a Condor’ s, so it is fine to open both at once. The cockpit is 1 . 02 metres wide – 10 cm wider than a 152’ s – but feels even roomier still, thanks to its low canopy sills and extensive transparency. This, plus the slim canopy and windscreen support tubes, downward-sloping upper engine cowling, and a low instrument panel combine to give exceptionally good forward visibility {for a|for any|to get a} tailwheeler.

Both aeroplanes’ seats have very comfortable (and safe) conformal foam cushions, although, {because the|since the|as the} squabs are a little thicker {than the|compared to|compared to the} originals, the never-excess headroom might suffer slightly. The red SAN D. 117 has a blown ‘ bubble’ windscreen, while the blue Wassmer D. 120A’ s screen is a simpler, single-curvature perspex or plexiglas sheet.

Most Jodels have simple but adequate instrumentation. G-BBPS’ s standard panel contains six primary instruments: ASI, compass, VSI, altimeter, turn-and-slip and tachometer. {To the left is|Left is} a quirkily Gallic multifunction fuel gauge, indicating {the selected|the chosen} tank’ s contents, but supplementing this with warning lights for both low fuel and low oil pressure and also, for some strange reason, generator amps. The similarly unconventional French magneto switch is alongside – this rotating knob is pulled out to select both mags on and then rotated {left and right|right and left} to switch off either {in turn|consequently|subsequently}. The last small knob controls cabin heat, and there is no parking brake (another D. 120 luxury).

Along the panel’ s bottom are push-pull knobs for mixture, throttle and carby heat, with the yellow rotating fuel selector in the middle. The starter button and fuses are over on your right, while a neat radio is installed down on the left. Other Jodels {might have|may have|could have} more or less instrumentation or even be completely lacking in electrics, necessitating hand-swinging the propeller. {This might|This may|This could} seem anachronistic in the 21st Century, {but it|however it|nonetheless it} does keep the airframe ultra-light, and is no chore {with these|using these|with one of these} easy-starting Continentals (I have two, and they both {start at|from} the first gentle swing after six priming turns).

Like Rallyes and Austers, all Jodels’ dual control columns are joined at a centre-cockpit hinge, {so the|therefore the|and so the} hand-grips move up and down through a small arc {as the|since the|because the} sticks are moved from side-to-side but , having initially noticed it, you will soon forget this eccentricity. Some Jodels have one or two throttles working up and down in vertical slots in the panel (as both these examples once did). Again, although unusual, {in practice|used} and with familiarity, this presents no problems.

As expected, with its electric starter, this little C-90 started easily after a couple of priming pumps on the throttle. The aeroplane’ s simple suspension is just a stack of hollow oval rubber blocks in compression, but nevertheless comfortable, {if a|in case a|if the} little stiff. The steerable tailwheel makes gentle turns easy, but only the left occupant has brake pedals and, being suspended above, inboard and separate {from the|from your|through the} rudder pedals, these are {not as|less|much less} well positioned as they {might be|may be|could be}. Like many Jodel pilots, to turn while taxying, {I found|I discovered|I came across} myself first applying full right rudder and then dabbing the right brake pedal with my left toes {for a|for any|to get a} really tight turn. Andy warned against turning too tightly when solo, or without any fuel in the rear tank – many a Jodel has been tipped up and broken its propeller in this way.

Despite only producing a mere 90 horses, the small Continental endows this lightweight aeroplane {with a|having a|using a} remarkably good takeoff and climb, especially considering {this is a|it is a|this can be a} full 20 per cent less power (and therefore lower fuel consumption) than in {even a|a} humble Cessna 152. {You need|You require|You will need} quite a lot of right rudder deflection to keep straight, but the pedal pressure is not high, {and the|as well as the|plus the} aeroplane is so light, accelerates so rapidly and lifts off at such a low speed that this does not {last for|are} long. We were airborne {after a|following a|after having a} mere 150m in a temperature of 20° C and into a gentle 10kt headwind. With no flaps to retract and no electric pump {to turn|to show|to choose} off, there are no after takeoff checks, which is always nice. The climb rate, two-up, was around 800ft/min, which is remarkably good on just 90hp (67kW).

All this delightful aeroplane’ s controls are light and effective. The ailerons might be a little heavier {than the|compared to|compared to the} elevator and the rudder, but barely so. Even {at a|in a|with a} fast 125kt they were not unduly heavy, and caused just a little adverse yaw {at all|whatsoever|in any way} speeds. Stability is good {in all|in most|in every} three axes, and {despite it being|lthough it is} a bumpy day, {I could|I possibly could|I really could} find no evidence of a mild Dutch Roll some other writers have mentioned. In fact , the aircraft is so very stable that it will fly for extended periods with your hands and feet completely {clear of|free from} the controls, which is quite unusual for a low-winged aeroplane. Some writers have suggested Jodels were approved in France for aerobatics. This is not true, and people have occasionally been hurt attempting to aerobat these elderly airframes in recent years, {although they are|even though are|whilst they are} significantly stronger than Cherokees or Cessnas.

A look at G-BBPS in the air. (Bob Grimstead)

{A look at|A glance at|A review of} G-BBPS in the air. (Bob Grimstead)

{To get the best|For the most powerful} from such a clean airframe, it’ s important to settle it ‘ on the step’ by climbing a little above your intended altitude, setting power, trimming out any slight residual elevator force, and then letting the aeroplane gently subside to the required height. For pilots {used to|utilized to|accustomed to} less efficient aircraft, the nose seems very low {in the|within the|inside the} cruise, giving excellent forward visibility. Even knowing {about this|relating to this|concerning this} characteristic, I still found myself climbing a couple of times before finally getting the attitude and trim precisely right. The elevator tab trimmer {is a|is really a|is actually a} tiny lever on the left sidewall, turning through a 120-degree arc. Quite sensitive, it is also {useful for|helpful for|great for} getting the trim exactly correct.

Wooden airframes absorb vibration better than metal ones, so a comfortable 2350rpm gave us a commendably smooth 95kt IAS at 2500ft, making a neat 100kt TAS. Andy’ s previous Evra prop gave him five more knots, {but was|unfortunately he} more expensive than this current Newton one – {both are|the two are} wooden. Some poorer propellers will inevitably spoil this performance a little, so it pays to shop around.

With a properly leaned 18 to 20-l/hr consumption, full tanks allow a theoretical five hours of cruising or a 500nm range with 45 minutes reserve.

The canopy’ s draught sealing looks rudimentary (and it can be difficult to source replacements) but it actually works well in flight; the airflow noise is reasonable, and we experienced {none of|nothing of} those piercing wind blasts you get in some other types.

The Jodel’ s low speed handling is every bit as good as its other traits, although everything happens at incredibly low airspeeds. Since the payload can be {such a|this type of|this kind of} high proportion of its total mass, both cruise and stall speeds vary significantly with weight. At 558kg, we were at around 90 per cent of the maximum allowable, and with a forward C of G. Like most aeroplanes of its generation, the Jodel has no artificial electric stall warner, although a 1959 British Airworthiness Directive required small triangular stall ‘ breaker strips’ to be glued to the inboard leading-edges {to provide|to supply|to offer} some aerodynamic buffeting {over the|on the|within the} elevators to provide natural stall warning.

The classic Jodel cranked wing uses the common NACA 23012 aerofoil. The red example here has no flaps, but the otherwise similar blue one has the under-belly airbrakes that work like flaps for landing. (Bob Grimstead)

The classic Jodel cranked wing uses the common NACA 23012 aerofoil. The red example here has no flaps, but the otherwise similar blue one has the under-belly airbrakes that work like flaps for landing. (Bob Grimstead)

I found the handling quite normal {in all|in most|in every} axes at as low an airspeed as 40kt, but would you believe that the ASI needle had to come {all the way|completely|all the way up} back to an indicated 29kt before, with a slight judder and a straightforward nose-drop, we eventually stalled. When I held the stick hard back against the rear stops, this willing little aeroplane just sank gently, nodding and wallowing a little, but still under full control. I suspect the max weight, aft C  of  G stall would be a little less benign, but I have no reason to believe it would actually be unpleasant.

Returning to base, I found it surprisingly {difficult to|hard to|challenging to} slow down and descend, so unexpectedly clean is this airframe. For the same reason, I found 600 foot circuits much easier than 1000 foot ones. With such simple systems, {there is|there is certainly|there exists} little to check, except that fuel is selected from the front tank for the approach and landing. All my approaches {were made|were created} with the throttle closed – the safest way – with a little sideslip to vary the descent angle. The glide angle is quite shallow, {but if|when|in case} needed, full rudder {gives a|provides a|provides} twenty degree banked sideslip, doubling the descent rate.

Andy’ s recommended 50kt approach speed initially struck me as frighteningly slow, but a moment’ s mental arithmetic confirmed that, with a 29kt stall, 1 . 3 times that, or just 40kt knots, {might be|may be|could be} okay with some allowance for gusts. Sure enough, at my initial 55kt we floated {after the|following the|following your} flare, thanks to the ground cushion developed under this long, low wing. Subsequently, 50kt gave me more than adequate control, and felt much more comfortable, while Andy assured me that a 45kt approach was no problem, {and even|as well as|and also} 40kt knots was feasible on a calm day.

The flare and hold-off were instinctive, {and it was|also it was|and it also was} dead easy to {make a|create a|produce a} succession of three-point touchdowns of gradually increasing gentleness. This is a delightful aeroplane to fly, and one of the easiest tailwheelers to land, provided, as with all taildraggers, you concentrate, and stop any directional deviation before it gets started. As I said at the beginning, {it is a|this is a|it is just a} ‘ friendly’ aeroplane, {and it was|also it was|and it also was} a real pleasure {to renew|to resume} my acquaintance with the marque.

If you fancy an inexpensive, nice-flying, short-field, efficient two-seat cruiser and have reasonable foot/eye coordination, you should consider a Jodel (if you can find one).

The Jodel’s low-speed handling is every bit as good as its other traits, although everything happens at incredibly low airspeeds. (Bob Grimstead)

The Jodel’ s low-speed handling is every bit {as good as|as effective as|just like} its other traits, although everything happens at incredibly low airspeeds. (Bob Grimstead)

This article originally appeared {in the|within the|inside the} November 2008 edition of Australian Aviation. To read more stories like this, {become a member of|enroll in} Australian Aviation here .

Advertisement